- It's the primary cookbook I use, and as such is very well-loved.
- It's also guilty of some of the most mind-boggling problems I have with the paleo community.
Some of the reviews said it was "blah" and not very creative. Personally, for me, there's lots of diversity here and I really recommend this book if you're good at following directions.
There are some things about it I don't like, though. It's one of those resources that I look at and just think "Good Gods, people don't really have a concept of what paleo is, do they?" It has some ingredients that are more "disputed" than actually forbidden, like honey and maple syrup. It used to be that paleo explicitly excluded these, but now they're pretty regularly found in recipes. She seems convinced that cashews are not paleo. This is a common misconception; people often either mistakenly think they are legumes or mistakenly think they can't be eaten raw. A select few think it's non-paleo specifically because of the high omega-6 (which it shares with a lot of other nuts and seeds). But it's one of those things where I read it and just roll my eyes.
More bizarrely, she includes an entire section on alcoholic beverages. So cashews are so "obviously" (she uses that word) un-paleo, but a Tom Collins isn't?
There are also no pictures in this book. That's not a big deal, it's a cookbook, but often when it comes to food I'm at a loss as to what it's actually supposed to look like. But there's a bright side to this: No pictures means that she's probably not faking pictures (someday I'll review my book on making paleo bread and we'll talk about that one; it's actually a huge problem in vegetarian cookbooks oddly enough).